Toys Category IconProducts

Best Dog Toys for Pitbulls: Ratings, Reviews, & Top Picks

Looking for the perfect dog toy for your Pitbull? We compare our favorite dog toys that can withstand all the abuse and jaw pressure your Pitbull can throw at them!

Emma Braby

Last Updated: November 3, 2020 | 15 min read

Pitbull Chewing a Dog Toy

The American Pitbull Terrier is a fun and energetic dog who needs lots of physical stimulation. Pitbulls also need plenty of daily mental stimulation as well. And as much as we wish we could, we cannot spend 24/7 playing with our wonderful Pitties. And this is where finding the best dog toy for your Pitbull pup steps in.

But not any old toy will do for the Pitbull. Typically, he needs tough heavier duty toys that can stand up to the strength of his jaws and tenacity. Picking the wrong toy will likely result in your pup destroying it in under an hour. Unfortunately, when this happens, your pocketbook pays, as does your frustration level with your dog.

Using that information, we have scaled the internet looking for the best toys for the Pitbull. There are hundreds, if not thousands of different products out there. We’ve handpicked our favorites that can withstand the bite pressure that these dogs are famous for. This way, you can spend less time trawling through online stores and more time playing with your pup.

At a Glance: Our Favorite Pitbull Dog Toys

Kong Extreme Giant Toy
Our Rating

Best Overall

Kong Extreme

View at Chewy.com
Nylabone Dinosaur Durachew Budget
Our Rating

Best Value

Nylabone Durachew

View at Chewy.com
Vanfine Dog Toy
Our Rating

Popular Pick

Vanfine Squeaky Toy

View at Amazon.com

Note: Clicking the above links will take you to Chewy.com or Amazon.com, where you can get additional product information and customer reviews. If you make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.

Buyers Guide

Dog Chewing Kong Toy
Before purchasing a dog toy for your pup, there are a few things to consider.

Before we showcase our recommendations, we need to talk to you about the factors you need to consider before buying just any old toy. From the strength required to the size and materials, we have covered everything. As a Pitbull-type dog mom, I know just how tricky it is. But, there is hope, so read our guide, and we will help you find the perfect toy for your pup.

Type of Play

The first thing to think about is t what type of toy your dog likes. There’s no good buying a tough rubber ring if he prefers to play with balls, and vice versa. The purpose of the toy is to be fun and enjoyable for him, as well as keep him entertained. There’s no point in buying it if it’s just going to sit in a box and look pretty. First and foremost, work with what he likes.

Durability

This is one of the trickiest considerations. How do you know it is going to stand up to the jaws of your Pitbull until he destroys it? The secret here is to purchase toys that are heavy-duty and designed for dogs with strong jaws. They usually come with a higher price tag. But they will last much longer than others, and it will save you money in the long run.

You also need to remember that no toy is going to last forever. Especially if your dog plays with it a lot. If it lasts longer than a month or so, we say that it is ideal for the breed. Just like the Pope is Catholic, the Pits are some of the toughest canine chewers out there.

Materials

Materials and durability come hand in hand. If it isn’t the right material, it isn’t going to be durable. Pitbulls are active and adventurous. Not only do they need to be up to the task of lots of playing, but they should also be up to fetching and playing in mud if he is an outdoorsy pooch. They also need to be able to withstand the strength of his teeth and jaw. You have two choices of material, and these are:

Rubber: Rubber is typically your best option. It is tough and takes a lot to chew it apart. They are great for fetching and rolling around in the mud. It will also feel good on his teeth and gums. Rubber is the best toy material for teething puppies because it will satisfy their need to chew. They can be washed easily, allowing you to get rid of mud and drool. Rubber toys must be seal free to increase their longevity.

Rope: Most dogs love to play tug-of-war, and there is no better material for this than rope. The rope is strong, durable, and lasts a long time. Rope will not last forever, but it will not cause a choking hazard compared to other materials when it does start to deteriorate. When you begin noticing rope string around your house, it’s probably time to get a new one.

Nylon: Although nylon isn’t going to hold up against the strongest jaws, it is better than other types of materials for those Pitbulls who arent power chewers. Some dogs do not like rubber or rope. So you need to find a product, like a few of our recommendations below, that are made with reinforced nylon. Nylon is also a popular Pitbull harness material, due to the level of abuse it can take.

Safety

Toys need to be fun, but safety should always come first. The right size is essential, as is material because the wrong pick can cause a choking hazard. It is also important to consider whether the material it is made of is safe. Natural rubber is safe and toxin-free. Products made in the USA tend to be much safer than those made in other countries.

Many of the tough toy options that we have recommended have a safety indicator. As your Pitbull chews it, over time, it will breakdown and reach the safety indicator. Once you see this indicator, you know it’s time to buy a new one. Not only are these ideal for dogs with strong jaws, but they will also give you peace of mind too.

Size

The Pitbull is a medium-sized dog, so you need to buy a toy designed for medium-sized dogs and above. Toys suitable for a Pomeranian are not going to cut it with this breed. The wrong size can be a choking hazard, and he could swallow it whole! Look at the measurements and dimensions, then look at your dog’s mouth. If he could fit it in whole, it isn’t suitable for him. If your dog is on the larger end of the spectrum, consider a Jolly ball or another giant toy.

Best Dog Toys for Pitbulls

Pitbull Chewing Dog Toy
Below are our favorite dog toys for your Pitbull.

Now we have arrived at the best bit, our recommendations. If we had to pick only one dog toy, we’d pick the Kong Extreme as our favorite. But with that being said, most dog parents don’t just buy one. You’ll want an assortment, so we’ve compiled a full list of our favorites. Each toy is made with the best materials and manufactured by the best brands. This means that they are fun and safe. They have all been tried and tested too, and highly rated by other doggy parents that own pups with strong jaws.

We have also found something for every Pitbull owner’s budget. So you can be sure that there is something here for everyone. So, here we have our favorite toys for your pup, in no particular order.


Nylabone Dinosaur Chew Toy

Nylabone Dinosaur Durachew
  • Budget-friendly.
  • Large size is perfect for Pitbulls.
  • Long-lasting and durable.
  • Ridges help keep teeth clean.
  • One of three different dinosaur shapes.
  • Made with tough & durable nylon.
  • Made for extreme chewing styles.
View at Chewy.com

This DuraChew is a nylon-made chew toy that is designed to withstand abuse.  The large size is designed for dogs up to 50 pounds in weight, making it a perfect size. It is recommended by veterinarians, and it is made in the USA for peace of mind.

Thankfully, this chew toy tastes of chicken, which you pup is bound to go crazy for. The chicken flavor is infused throughout, right until the end, so the taste will not fade.

It is designed in the shape of a dinosaur, and the manufacturer will surprise you with one of three dinosaurs. Each dinosaur has nodules that are designed to help breakdown plaque and massage his gums. So not only is it good for his brain, it is good for his dental health too. If you are dissatisfied with the product, you can contact the manufacturer for a replacement.

We love that this product is made with nylon, so it is designed to be long-lasting, even for dogs with strong bites.


Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball

Chuckit Original Ball Toy
  • Budget-friendly.
  • Comes in four different sizes.
  • Orange coloring is easy to see.
  • Specifically designed for games of fetch.
  • Compatible with Chuckit! brand launcher.
  • Floating ball for water play.
  • Extra thick-rubber for strong jaws.
View at Chewy.com

Chuckit! has created this ball for those dogs who love to play fetch but are have some serious bite force. The rubber is extra thick, meaning that it is durable. But it is also designed to float on water, so if your dog is a water-baby, it is fantastic for him. This is one of the highest-rated toys for dogs with a strong bite force, so you almost be certain it will impress your Pibble.

The ball is brightly colored so that you can find it in the long grass or making it more visible in low lighting. It also bounces super high, meaning you can get extra out of this ball compared to most others.  They are compatible with Chuckit! ball launchers, so if you are already an avid fan of this brand, you can keep replacing the balls without having to buy another launcher.

We love that this rubber ball is bouncy and perfect for active dogs who love to play fetch.


Benebone Bacon Flavor Dog Toy

Benebone Giant Toy
  • Ergonomic design.
  • Four different sizes.
  • Real bacon flavor.
  • Will keep dogs entertained for long periods.
  • A portion of each sale goes to charity.
  • Durable and easy to grip.
  • Made in the United States.
View at Chewy.com

The Benebone is another nylon bone designed to last for ages, making it much better value for money than other chew toys. Ergonomically designed, it is shaped like a wishbone. Which some Pitbull’s find much easier to grip compared to stand-alone bones. If you look at it, you could say it’s a three-in-one bone.

It’s great for his oral hygiene too. It is rounded and paw-friendly with no sharp edges. It is meat-flavored, and the entire toy is infused with bacon ingredients. Meaning the flavor will not disappear over time. It also comes in other delicious flavors.

It is made in the USA, and it is completely safe for your pup. The packaging and ingredient sourcing are all ethical, meaning you can rest assured it is good for the environment. In addition to this, Benebone donates a portion of their sales to animal welfare organizations across the USA. So, your money will also be going to a good cause. Benebone suggests that this will last around a month for heavy chewers.

We love that this toy is made with real bacon, meaning that it will keep your dog’s brain and tastebuds entertained for hours on end.


Kong Extreme Dog Toy

Kong Extreme XXL Toy
  • Irregular shape makes it easy to grip.
  • Unpredictable bounce is perfect for fetch.
  • Five different sizes.
  • Extremely durable rubber.
  • Can put treats inside.
  • Endorsed by veterinarians.
  • Made in the United States.
View at Chewy.com

Every dog owner in the world has either owned a Kong at some point in their lifetime or at least heard of them. But this isn’t just any old Kong. This is Kong’s extreme version, designed specifically for dogs with strong bites. Kong makes great toys, for just about every breed and size. In fact, they are one of our favorite toys for the Labrador Retriever, as well as other active breeds.

The large Kong is the best size for the Pitbull according to their size instructions. Ensure that you get the right size because there have been horror stories of dogs swallowing a Kong (make it three!) whole. It is made in the USA with safe and durable rubber. It is approved and used by veterinarians and dog trainers, so you can be sure that it will meet all your dog’s needs and more.

Its ergonomic shape means that it is easy to grip, and when thrown, it will bounce erratically. Meaning not every throw is the same, which is great for stimulating his mind. It can also be stuffed with treats. But for an extra special treat, why not buy their Stuff’n’Easy Peanut Butter Treat Filling. It also comes in many other flavors.

We love that this toy is treat-dispensing, meaning that if your Pittie is a forever hungry pooch, he will love this product. It’s also great that it acts as a puzzle as well, which stimulates your dog’s mind.


Starmark Treat Dispensing Toy

Starmark Treat Dispensing Toy
  • Treat-dispensing design.
  • Helps nurture natural foraging behaviors.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Reduces boredom.
  • Can use treats or dog food.
  • Floats in water.
  • Great mental stimulation
View at Chewy.com

This is another bouncy ball, and again, it is ideal for dog breeds that have some serious jaw pressure. In all honesty, it doesn’t look like it is all that durable when you first look at it. But when reading the description and fantastic reviews, you know that it will stand up to the test. It is made with a thermoplastic elastomer, which is super tough. It is also free of all the nasty ingredients that can cause reactions in dogs.

This puzzle toy is ideal for intelligent thinkers or those that need a real challenge to get the treats out. If you aren’t sure whether your Pitbull will be up to the challenge of working this one out, use small treats. They will fall out easier and keep him interested. Once he has the hang of it, increase the size of the treats for more of a challenge.

It will distract your dog away from destructive behaviors in the home, and it will keep him entertained for hours on end. This toy bounces extremely well, which is great for retrieving games. It also floats in water, making it a good option for canines who like to have a splashing good time. Starmark makes this toy dishwasher safe for an easy clean, and it is made with natural rubber that is totally safe.

We love that Starmark makes this product treat-dispensing but with a difference. It is an interlocking design that means your pup has to puzzle-solve.


GoughNuts Tug Dog Toy Maxx

Goughnuts Dog Tug Toy
  • Great for tug of war.
  • Design makes for easy gripping.
  • Protects your hands during play.
  • Durable rubber design.
  • Great for play with tough chewers.
  • Natural rubber construction.
  • Made in the United States.
View at Chewy.com

GoughNuts is another well-known brand who are known for their almost indestructible dog toys, just like Kong. It’s is also made of durable natural rubber and engineered carbon reinforcement. Made in the USA, you can be sure that this product is safe.

This toy is from the red range designed for interactive play rather than as a constant chewing toy. But, thanks to its thick rubber design, it can take a fair bit of chewing compared to most other products out there.

The figure of eight design means that you can place your hands on one hand, and his mouth can be on the other. Meaning safety for whoever is playing tug of war. This toy is designed for larger dogs, as it;s a decent size. GoughNuts recommends that if you allow older children to play tug of war with your Pitbull, or other dogs, always supervise them just in case things get ‘ruff.’

We love that this toy is designed for larger pups who love to play tug of war. Either with his humans or his doggy siblings.


Mammoth Cotton Blend Rope

Mammoth Cottonblend 3 Knot Dog Rope
  • Budget-friendly.
  • Made from all-natural cotton.
  • Doubles as a flossing agent.
  • Great for fetch and tug of war.
  • Built for long periods of play.
  • Great option for puppies & younger dogs.
  • Should only be used during supervision.
View at Chewy.com

This rope toy is made with rope, using a 100% natural cotton blend that will help to floss his teeth as he plays. It has five large knots along the continuous piece of rope, which gives both you and your dog a place to grip. Or his other canine siblings if you are lucky enough to own more than one dog.

It is built to be tough and strong, and it is great for tugging, tossing, and interactive play. This is also a great option is also great for teething puppies according to Mammoth. As it is cotton, you can chuck it into the washing machine for an easy clean. The manufacturer will ship this product in an assortment of colors, meaning that you are in for a surprise on delivery day.

We love rope toys, and this is the only one on this list. So if your pup isn’t a big fan of rubber, this option is a fantastic option for him.


Kong Large Classic Wubba

Kong Wubba
  • Three different sizes.
  • Great for tug or fetch.
  • Has a squeaky end.
  • Squeaker will keep your dog busy for hours.
  • Reinforced fabric.
  • Available in three colors.
  • Durable nylon for longevity.
View at Chewy.com

We have decided to go with another Kong toy because it offers many different options. Although this is not intended as a chew toy, it is designed for active pups. It is made with durable outer ballistic nylon material, and it is reinforced with stitching too. Kong’s Wubba comes in three colors, which will be kept as a surprise until you receive it.

It is designed with two balls at one end, with one being a tennis ball and the other being a squeaky ball. So not only does it bounce, but it also squeaks when he plays with it. Its ergonomic design helps it fly through the air, making it ideal for fetch games. The balls and tails also mean that it makes for fun tug of war games. Overall, this is a super-versatile product that will stimulate most dogs.

We love that this toy is perfect for Pitbulls, who love to grab and shake thanks to the tails on the end.


Arm & Hammer Super Gorilla

Treads Arm and Hammer Dog Treat
  • Budget-friendly.
  • Comes in two different sizes and styles.
  • Freshens breath.
  • Reduces tartar.
  • Made with baking soda.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Stands up to intense jaw pressure.
View at Amazon.com

Arm & Hammer are famous for their human oral hygiene products, and now they have expanded to doggy dental hygiene. So if it’s good enough for you, it’s good enough for your pup. It is shaped liked a Gorilla, with lots of grooves for his teeth to get into. Not only is this toy infused with baking soda, but you can spread doggy toothpaste into it for an extra cleaning boost.

This dental toy is designed for aggressive chewers, so you can be sure it will last longer than a standard dental toy. It is made with natural rubber and completely safe for your Pitbull. It’s also a treat-dispensing as well, so it offers metal stimulation and hours of fun. The manufacturer states that satisfaction is guaranteed and if you aren’t happy to contact them. It can be chucked into the dishwasher for easy and regular cleaning.

We love that this toy is also designed with oral hygiene in mind. Not only is it tough, but it is infused with baking soda for an extra deep dental clean.


VanFine Almost Indestructible Toy

Vanfine Dog Toy For Pitbulls
  • Squeak toy will keep your Pitbull busy.
  • Made with natural rubber.
  • Well known to withstand intense bite force.
  • Lifetime replacement guarantee.
  • Made of non-toxic materials.
  • Great for fetch, or just for chewing.
  • Two different and unique designs.
View at Chewy.com

Last but certainly not least, we have this squeaky toy. We don’t usually recommend squeaky dog toys for anything other than a small pup, but this one is described as practicably indestructible. Making it ideal for dogs with a strong bite.

VanFine makes this toy with a natural rubber that is safe for dogs, and it is eco-friendly. It’s soft enough to get that bounce, but tough too. You can purchase it in one of two shapes, but we think the cube shape is much better than the cylinder shape for maximum abuse.

It can also be used as a fetch toy, and its shape means it bounces around erratically, which will keep your Pitbull on his toes. Uniquely designed, it also has ridges to help clean teeth, and it is flavored with 100% natural beef ingredients to keep his tastebuds interested. VanFine offers a six-month money-back guarantee, so if your dog does destroy it, you can get your money back.

We love that this is a squeaker. Finally, a squeaky toy that can stand up to tough chewers who go mad for the squeak.


Frequently Asked Questions

When it comes to the Pitbull, many owners have questions about what toys to get them. As well as many other things toy-related. Here are just some of the most commonly asked questions.

Q: What types of toys are best for my Pitbull?

A: Every dog is different, and individual dogs like different types of toys. Generally speaking, Pitbulls need tougher toys than most because they are strong and tenacious in their play. Not all dogs will like, or need, the toughest products. Once you’ve welcomed your pup home, invest in a variety of different options, and work out what he likes. If he loves them all, that’s great! If not, see which one he likes and focus on that type in the future.

Q: Are there any completely 100% indestructible dog toys available?

A: Unfortunately, no. No dog toy is indestructible, and if you notice that the toy is starting to break down, you need to replace it with a new one immediately. Broken toys can be a choking hazard. If your dog is a power chewer, he may need a size or two up, as this might help it last a bit longer.

Q: Is one good toy enough, or do I need more?

A: Although one good toy is better than two poor-quality toys, we would suggest getting a handful of tough toys for your pup. Pitbulls are very intelligent dogs, and they will get bored with just one. Buying two or three as a minimum will stimulate his brain and prevent him from getting up to mischief. We suggest rotating his toys throughout the week to keep his interest piqued.

Q: Are some toy materials dangerous?

A: Most dog toys are safe, especially if sold on a reputable online market and stores. However, some have been found to contain high levels of chemicals that can be harmful to your pooch when ingested. Read the description, and look for familiar materials such as 100% natural rubber, polyester, and nylon. Look for toys that are latex and BPA free.

Q: Why do Pitbulls destroy their toys?

A: Good question. But most of the time, it is simply because they love to play and are having so much fun. Plus, they are very strong and stubborn, meaning that they will play for hours on end. If your dog is an aggressive chewer, look for toys that are heavy-duty. They might be slightly more expensive, but they might prevent him from chewing all your furniture. So, it will work out cheaper in the long run.

Q: My Pitbull has swallowed his toy, what do I do?

A: Firstly, don’t panic. Assess the situation and understand what is going on. Is your dog struggling to breathe or showing signs of discomfort? If he is, you need to get him down to the vet immediately. If he isn’t, and he is sitting there wagging his tail wondering why you are fussing, it is probably going to be ok. Keep an eye on him and his poop over the next few days. If he has swallowed smaller toy parts, he should pass it. If in doubt, ring your vet and ask for advice.

Final Thoughts

The perfect Pitbull is man’s best friend. And what better way to show him your love than to invest in a bunch of toys that are equally as fantastic as he is. We created this guide because we know that the struggle is real when finding your Pitbull a toy. Especially if you want it to last longer than just a few minutes. But hopefully, after reading our recommendations, you have found one, or maybe a few toys, that you think your pup will love.

Dog toys are not a luxury, they are a necessity, especially for the pocket-rocket interactive Pitbull. They can keep him physically and mentally stimulated throughout the day, and will keep him entertained when you haven’t got enough time to play. And they are great to prevent him from destroying furniture and shoes too. And when you play with him, it will strengthen your bond tenfold.

Leave a Comment