Comparing Diamond Naturals vs. Taste of the Wild for your furry friend’s next meal? Finding the perfect food for your pup is important. That’s why it’s quite common to compare bigger brands that offer foods with a limited ingredient list, like these two popular brands.
Your dog’s diet plays a huge role in their overall health. It’s essential to choose a brand that serves your dog’s nutritional needs in every way. With so many quality options available to dog owners today, it can be tough to determine which food is best for your furry friend. In order to help you narrow down your search, we’re comparing Diamond Naturals and Taste Of The Wild to find the perfect food for your canine companion.
Today we’ll discuss the details of each brand when it comes to their formulas varieties, flavor options, brand history, recall history, and more! By the end of this article, we hope to make your decision between Diamond Naturals and Taste of the Wild dog food a bit easier. Let’s get started!
Top Pick For Puppies
Diamond Naturals Puppy
Top Pick For Adults
Taste of the Wild Adult
Top Pick For Seniors
Diamond Naturals Senior
Note: Clicking the above links will take you to Chewy.com, where you can get additional product information and customer reviews. If you make a purchase, we earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Brand History
Each dog food brand has had a long journey to where they are now, adding to the uniqueness that each brand has to offer. Let’s discuss the history of both Diamond Naturals and Taste of the Wild dog food to better understand their mission.
It may surprise you to learn, that both Diamond Naturals and Taste of the Wild are actually owned by the same company. Diamond Pet Foods is owned by Schell & Kampeter, which actually owns both brands. It’s important to distinguish that these are two completely different brands. They just happen to be owned by the same company. Let’s jump in and look at the history of each dog food, and what their purpose is.
Diamond Naturals
The Diamond Naturals pet food company has been a prominent name in the dog food arena since 1970. With growing to be one of the largest dog food manufacturers in the last decade, they have become a well-known name in the pet food industry. Though this company has grown exponentially over the years.
Diamond Naturals still takes pride in their midwestern family values that they took pride in when first creating their company. They aim to offer natural diets that they would be proud to feed their own pets. This is one of the many reasons so many dog owners love their food. We’ve compared Diamond Naturals to Science Diet and several other dog food brands in the past. They are also one of our favorite dog foods for the following breeds in their puppy stages:
Taste Of The Wild
Taste Of The Wild dog food has always had a passion of bringing dogs back to their natural roots since 2007. They have become famous for their high protein diets that cater to our dog’s inner wolf. Taste of the Wild aims to offer a diet that is as authentic to this “wild dog” premise as possible. With being owned and manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods, they produce Taste of the Wild and several other food brands.
Since this brand’s start in 2007, Taste of the Wild dog food has gained popularity in the eyes of consumers and veterinary professionals.With having only one recall in their history and offering diets with quality protein, they have proven to be a diet that you can trust! We’ve compared Taste of the Wild to several other high quality brands. Some of those comparisons include the following:
- Taste of the Wild vs. Nutro
- Taste of the Wild vs. Orijen
- Taste of the Wild vs. American Journey
- Taste of the Wild vs. Merrick
- Taste of the Wild vs. Blue Buffalo
Overall, Taste of the Wild is an extremely high-quality brand with an excellent recall history. That’s partially the reason we’ve put them against other dog food heavyweights so many times. Next, we look at the recall history for both brands.
Recalls
Now that we’ve introduced you to the Diamond Naturals and Taste Of The Wild brands, let’s discuss their individual past with dog food recalls throughout their years in the pet food business. The way a brand approaches each recall can say a lot about their mission and can help us understand which brands have our dog’s best interest at heart.
Diamond Naturals
Diamond Naturals has had four food recalls throughout their history in the pet food business. Keep in mind that food brands that are more established and have been around a while, will typically have more recalls. The recalls that have come from Diamond Naturals include:
December 2005: This recall involved the possible contamination of aflatoxin in many of their diets created in their South Carolina facility.
April 2012: This recall involved a possible salmonella contamination in multiple dry formulas.
May 2012: Yet another recall occurred due to a possible salmonella contamination in a few of their diets.
March 2013: The last recall involved low levels of thiamine in one of their kitten formulas.
Taste Of The Wild
Taste of the Wild has only experienced one recall since their start in 2012. This was a manufacture wide recall in all dog food that was produced at the Diamond Pet food facility, which therefore involved Taste Of The Wild dog food. Salmonella contamination was the cause of this recall, and unfortunately caused many pets around the country to become ill.
Food Ingredients
Each brand has their own unique traits to offer in terms of ingredients. The variety in each brand is what helps to set them apart from the rest, and is what ultimately helps us make our final decision in choosing a diet for our pups. Let’s dive into both Diamond Naturals and Taste Of The Wild dog food brands and see what they have to offer.
Diamond Naturals
The Diamond Naturals mission is stated clearly in their name; a natural approach to food. They aim to offer whole natural and nutritious ingredients. Diamond Naturals also focuses on antioxidant-rich ingredients that promote overall health. By offering a natural diet to every furry friend that consumes their food, they can help to promote blanched nutrition around the globe.
Diamond Naturals offers standard grain options and grain-free options for dogs with every need. Though they do contain meat meal in many of their diets, Diamond Naturals claims that this protein is still well sourced and contains 300% more protein than real meat. Along with their antioxidant-rich ingredients and quality protein, they also include DHA, probiotics, omega fatty acids, and more.
Taste Of The Wild
Taste Of The Wild focuses on offering ingredients that meet the nutritional needs of our dog’s ancient relatives. With our dogs still containing much of the same DNA as their wolf ancestors, they aim to provide this same nutrition that our dogs crave. In order to do this, they offer high protein diets with antioxidant rich ingredients for overall health.
Their main protein sources come from lamb, beef, salmon, and even venison. Along with their impressive protein ratios are the added probiotics for digestive health and healthy intestinal flora, fruits and veggies for antioxidants, and plenty of added minerals for immune support. With being a part of Diamond Pet Food and having such an impressive mission, this diet is widely popular among dog owners.
Range Of Formulas
Our dogs are often in our lives for many years, meaning they will experience multiple life stages throughout this time. Our dogs experience different nutritional needs as they pass through each period, meaning they need a diet that can cater to them during each stage.
Diamond Naturals offers 16 different diets that are split into age and size ranges, while Taste Of The Wild offers 21 different diets that range in formula options. In order to see which diet serves your canine companion best, let’s dive into both Diamond Naturals and Taste Of The Wild in terms of formula variety.
Puppy Formulas
Diamond Naturals Puppy
- Top pick for puppies.
- No corn, wheat, filler or artificial flavors.
- DHA for brain and vision health.
- Omega fatty acids for skin and coat.
- Powerful antioxidants for immune health.
- 342 Calories per cup.
- 27% Protein, 15% Fat, 3% Fiber.
Our growing canine friends need extra calories and nutrients to help them grow into healthy adults. It’s extremely important to find a diet that serves them best! Finding the right puppy food for your dog will set the building blocks for their adult life. It’s highly likely your pup will be eating their puppy formula until they reach 12 months in age. Let’s see what each brand has to offer in terms of puppy formulas.
Taste Of The Wild
Taste Of The Wild offers 2 puppy diets for our growing furry friends. One diet is in their Pacific Stream recipe, while the other is in their High Prairie Recipe. Each diet is packed with quality protein and DHA for healthy brain development.
Diamond Naturals
Diamond Naturals has 1 small breed puppy recipe, 1 large breed puppy recipe, and 1 diet that’s approved for all life stages, including nursing mothers and puppies. Chicken is the main ingredient in each diet, and is not grain free. Diamond naturals is consistently one of our favorite puppy foods for large breed dogs.
Winner
The winner of the puppy formulas round is Diamond Naturals Dog food due to their options of small or large breed puppy food. While Taste Of The Wild does offer quality puppy diets, they do not range in terms of puppy size.
Adult Formulas
Taste of the Wild Adult
- Top pick for adults.
- Made with real bison.
- Grain-free recipe.
- No corn, wheat or soy.
- Made in the United States.
- 370 Calories per cup.
- 32% Protein, 18% Fat, 4% Fiber.
Our dogs spend multiple years in their adult stage, meaning they need quality nutrition that can help them thrive during this time. Let’s see what each brand has to offer in terms of adult formulas!
Taste Of The Wild
Taste Of The Wild offers 13 dry kibble diets for our adult canine companions. 1 diet is for small breed dogs, 3 diets are limited ingredient recipes, and all diets are grain-free. Though most of their diets do not range in terms of breed size, they do vary greatly in terms of flavor. Their most popular flavor is the High Prairie recipe, and it contains real bison.
Diamond Naturals
Diamond Naturals offers 9 dry kibble diets and 1 diet that is approved for all life stages. These diets vary in terms of flavors, breed size, weight management, athletic ability, and a grain free option.
Winner
Though we are impressed with the diet options from Diamond Naturals, we love the added antioxidants and probiotics that Taste Of The Wild offers. With these qualities and their quality protein, Taste Of the Wild wins the adult formula round. They are consistently one of our favorite dog foods for smaller breeds like Pomskies.
Senior Formulas
Diamond Naturals Senior Formula
- Top pick for seniors.
- Nutrient dense formula.
- No corn, wheat or fillers.
- No preservatives.
- Glucosamine and Chondroitin boost.
- 318 Calories per cup.
- 25% Protein, 11% Fat, 3% Fiber.
Our senior canines need extra care when it comes to their diet. Their aging frame can benefit greatly from added ingredients to their daily diets, making it so important to find a diet that caters to senior pups specifically. Let’s see what each diet has to offer in terms of senior formulas.
Taste Of The Wild
Unfortunately, Taste Of The Wild does not offer a diet for senior dogs specifically. Though they do not have a senior formula, they claim that their adult diets have everything they need in terms of nutrition.
Diamond Naturals
Diamond Naturals has 1 diet made specifically for senior dogs, along with 1 diet that is created for dogs in all life stages. Their senior diet substitutes the standard chicken and rice recipe for chicken, oatmeal, and egg.
Winner
Since Taste Of The Wild does not offer a senior formula, Diamond Naturals wins this round. Though Taste Of The Wild claims their adult diets cater to senior friends, we just don’t see any added ingredients that can help our dogs age with ease.
Canned Food
Taste of the Wild Canned Food
- Top canned food pick.
- Grain-free recipe.
- Natural recipe.
- Omega fatty acids for skin and coat.
- Can be used as a topper or meal.
- 351 Calories per can.
- 8% Protein, 4.5% Fat, 1% Fiber.
Canned food is a great way to add extra flavor to your pup’s food, or even offer them an extra boost of daily hydration. Let’s see what each brand has to offer in terms of delicious canned recipes!
Taste Of The Wild
There are 5 different 5 canned food formulas produced by Taste of the Wild for our canine companions. These diets range in terms of flavors and are all completely grain-free. Each recipe is made for adult dogs.
Diamond Naturals
Diamond Naturals offers 3 canned diet options to our beloved companions. These canned diets range in the flavors of chicken,lamb, and beef. Each recipe is made for adult dogs.
Winner
Taste of The Wild wins the canned diet round for their range of delicious flavors. Though Diamond Naturals has a few quality canned diets to choose from, Taste Of the Wild seems to be the overall winner due to the popularity among dogs.
Final Thoughts
Overall, both dog foods have so much to offer in terms of quality ingredients and taste. With each brand having so many impressive qualities, we think this head to head comparison will have to end in a tie! We just can’t choose between the two.
Taste Of The Wild has stolen our hearts for their high protein diets. Their foods take our dogs back to their wild side. Diamond Naturals has followed through on its promise of offering natural and nutritious ingredients. At the end of the day, each brand has so much to offer.
If you are looking for a new diet for your beloved companion, both Taste Of The Wild and Diamond Naturals are wonderful options. We hope this head to head comparison can help you in choosing the best diet possible for your furry friend!
the Taste of Wild High Praire has little bison in it…it’s major ingredient is “Water Buffalo”. Which your article of “real bison” points out:
“…Now while most of us call Bison, Buffalo, they are not the same animal. Hundreds of years ago, early settlers arriving in North America who had come from Europe, mistook the Bison for their native Buffalo, and called them as such. The name, Buffalo, stuck, and ever since then Bison are commonly referred to as the American Buffalo, but there is in fact, no such thing.
Buffalo imported from Asia is a lot cheaper to import than to rear Bison in America, and many pet food brands import the Buffalo meat for this reason. Unfortunately, recent research has found that many dog food companies, even the premium brands, are deceiving their customers into thinking that they are buying bison, when in fact they are buying buffalo.
Bison isn’t Buffalo, so mislabeling products is a big problem! Some dogs are allergic to Buffalo, and if you unknowingly feed your pooch something that he is allergic to it could obviously have devastating consequences. Not only that, but Buffalo is not as nutritionally beneficial for your pup, so you are paying premium prices for a poorer protein.
Ultimately, consumers are being fooled into spending more money for less quality meat. So, the lesson here is to ensure that you read the ingredient list yourself and do not solely rely on packaging advertising or statements, and do not buy food that has replacement Buffalo ingredients if you want to feed your pooch top quality Bison food…”
I’m surprised ya’ll didn’t actually read the label contents prior to your review. If you had, “water buffalo” is the first listed, while “bison” is the 9th listed…this is why I don’t buy this food.
Hello. I have a 13 year old blind male Shi Tzu and a 9 year old semi active Border Collie ( we live in a apartment now for a mont so we try to walk her best we can) Before we moved my Border Collie was very active. I’ve fed them Taste of the Wild since I’ve have them. Well blue diamond first but the last very several years. Now that they are older, what is best for their diet to help them live the longest and most healthiest? Please?